The GoodSense brand of Acetaminophen is also a top pick among consumers, coming in at #2 among the best medicines for toothache. You can also mix dried ginger, licorice, and some cardamom seeds, and then apply it to your affected tooth. The following provides you an insight on the best painkillers for a toothache, you could use in almost every situation of a toothache.Ibuprofen is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID).Dentists consider it to be the best painkillers for a severe toothache. Then place it directly on your painful tooth. Using a cold ice pack is, in fact, considered to be the strongest painkillers for toothaches.The painkillers mentioned above are all very effective pain relievers, which alleviate your toothache. Looking out for the good painkillers for a toothache is a fancy. According to the data, anti-inflammatory analgesics like ibuprofen are the best for a toothache as the pain is typically caused by swelling. Dip it in some clove oil and apply it on your affected tooth and to the surrounding gum area. Answered on Oct 9, … Clove oil is a proven home remedy that would provide relief instantly for your toothache within seconds. Advil or Tylenol (acetaminophen) (if not allergic to these) may be a better choice for toothache pain. Cloves are also considered to be the best painkiller for toothache pain relief.Ginger root soothes many ailments. Some people would take the medications prescribed by a dentist and heal a toothache. Or perform an ice massage on the tooth that is paining. This would immediately alleviate the pain.Make use of an ice pack on your affected sore tooth. The reason is that Tylenol works on the nerve pain. On the other hand, Aleve (naproxen) works well for reducing inflammation and lasts longer than other nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. You should consult your dentist to find out the main reason for having a toothache. The oil gets mixed with saliva and becomes thick, creamy white when you spit out.A clove oil would be the best pain medicine for a toothache if you want some natural herbal medicines. Himalayan pink sea salt with organic garlic, organic lemon juice, and warm water… Remember that acetaminophen is not an NSAID so it can be taken on an empty stomach. Cinnamon (organic extract oil) and warm water mouthwash: no avail. Make sure you don’t swallow it because coconut oil penetrates bacteria and plaque that are present in your mouth. Advil (ibuprofen) better: I have found Aleve to be more effective in dealing with muscular aches and pains. Coconut oil for a toothache. It affects all your organs and, if you are lazy about it, you will suffer needlessly. Tip: Aleve (Naproxen) to Relieve Toothache Clove oil: dabbed a Q-tip in it and spread it in the affected area to no avail. Aleve is also used to temporarily reduce fever. But Tylenol medicine can’t be called as the best pain reliever for a toothache because it tends to heal a toothache naturally.Take 1 or 2 extra strength Tylenol 500mg available in over the counter every 4-6 hours.Peppermint oil is another best pain-killer for a toothache. Aleve (naproxen) is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID). You will see that your tooth pain is going down. Therefore, a toothache would have a different kind of remedy too.Some people may need the pulp tissue that is creating the tooth pain to be physically removed. Raw ginger helps to get rid of dental plaque from your teeth.Ginger root is considered as the herbal best toothache remedy. It is good for your gums and teeth. Rinse your mouth with warm water or salt water and brush well with regular toothpaste. This would provide you immediate relief. When having a toothache, ibuprofen would certainly provide you some relief from a painful tooth. Cut a piece of ginger root and remove its peel. Ibuprofen vs Aleve (Naproxen) – Which Is Better For Toothache? Soak a cotton ball in the mint oil and pack it around your painful tooth or soak a cotton swab and use it in the gum area surrounding the aching tooth.Coconut oil has lots of uses and it is another best pain reliever for tooth pain.Take 1 or 2 teaspoons of coconut oil in your mouth. See your dentist ASAP as it's only going to get worse. These are all the remedies that I used and the one that finally did the trick at 9:45 this morning!My advice is to try the remedies I listed above and see which works for you. Try to bite down a clove when having a persistent toothache and hold it there for a few minutes or so. Naproxen works by reducing hormones that cause inflammation and pain in the body. Most importantly, take good care of your dental hygiene. Ginger root relieves upset stomach, headaches, sprains, and bruises and treats ringworm.Ginger naturally contains anti-inflammatory properties in it and it is a powerful food. The peppermint oil contains properties, which have effects same of a local anesthesia provided by a dental professional.Mix 12 drops of peppermint oil into 3 tablespoons of neutral oil (canola oil, olive oil, grapeseed oil) to dilute the oil first because to prevent any irritation. Last night I had a menacing toothache that would not cease. Take 1 or 2 Ibuprofen (Advil) 200mg available in over the counter every 4-6 hours.Tylenol is one more medicine, which provides quick and fast relief to your any type of tooth pain problem.